Why transitions are hard for toddlers, and how to make them easier

Photo: Laura Ohlman / Unsplash
Transitions are hard for toddlers because they are asked to stop something they chose, often without warning, for something they didn't, at an age when they can't yet manage the frustration. Tantrums are most common between 1 and 3. What helps most is predictability: the same routine every day, a heads-up the child can see, a small choice, and calm consistency from you.
Why transitions are so hard for toddlers
- They don't know what's coming. HealthyChildren.org (from the American Academy of Pediatrics): when toddlers know what comes next, they have an easier time changing to that part of their day.
- Change itself is upsetting at this age. The AAP lists "objects to major changes in routine" among the typical emotional milestones of 2 year olds.
- Big feelings, few words. The NHS explains that toddlers want to express themselves but find it difficult; they feel frustrated, and the frustration comes out as a tantrum.
- Tired and hungry make it worse. The NHS names being tired or hungry as common reasons for a tantrum, and the AAP suggests carrying a snack if tantrums peak when your child is hungry. Those are exactly the times many transitions happen: leaving nursery, dinner, bedtime.
- Time is invisible. "In five minutes" means little to a 2 year old. They can't feel it coming, so the end of play arrives as a surprise.
When tantrums are most common
The AAP: tantrums are a normal part of development and happen most between ages 1 and 3; they tend to get better after 3. The NHS: they usually start at around 18 months, are very common in toddlers, and by the age of 4 are far less common.
Around the same ages, children are learning to follow routines. CDC's milestones for 30 months include following simple routines when told, like helping to pick up toys when you say "It's clean-up time", and following two-step instructions such as "Put the toy down and close the door." By 3, CDC suggests giving instructions with 2 or 3 steps.
Does a 5-minute warning work?
Warnings before a transition are common advice, and many families find them useful. The research is more mixed than the advice suggests:
- In a study of toddlers in a childcare setting, telling children about a transition 2 minutes before it began did not improve cooperation on its own; it helped only when combined with other changes in how adults responded (Cote, Thompson and McKerchar, 2005).
- In a study of two preschool children with tantrums at transitions, advance notice alone was ineffective; a different approach that rewarded calm behaviour reduced tantrums for both (Wilder and colleagues, 2006).
- A 2014 review of advance notice for children with developmental disabilities found many studies where it worked and others with negative results (Brewer and colleagues).
So a warning is worth giving, but don't expect it to do the job alone. What tends to make it work is everything around it: a predictable routine, something the child can see, a choice, and the same calm response every time. The AAP's parenting site has a useful twist: if warnings help your child, try a timer they set themselves, which helps them feel more in control.
How to make transitions easier
- Make the day predictable. CDC: routines and rules help kids feel safe and know what to expect. The AAP notes that toddlers with routines for bath time, bedtime and meals seem to have fewer power struggles with their parents.
- Say what happens next before it happens. "After blocks, it's bath." CDC suggests explaining before giving a direction: "It's time to go to the store. Please put on your shoes."
- Make the time visible. A sand timer, a kitchen timer they can watch, a pie that shrinks. The end of play becomes something your child sees coming.
- Offer a small choice. The AAP suggests giving children control over little things with small, directed choices rather than yes/no questions: "Hop or tiptoe to the bath?" not "Ready for your bath?"
- Keep it short and the same. CDC notes that with a toddler's short attention span, longer routines might be a challenge. If a routine has to change, tell your child when you're both calm.
- Be consistent. The AAP: consistency from day to day is key in reducing the level and frequency of tantrums. If the timer ends play on Monday, it ends play on Tuesday.
- Feed and rest. If tantrums peak when your child is hungry, the AAP suggests having a healthy snack with you.
- Notice when it goes well. CDC suggests praising your child each time they follow a direction.

From blocks to bath: an example
Here is how the pieces fit together in one ordinary transition. The wording is an example; use whatever sounds like you.
When it ends in a tantrum anyway
Some transitions will still end in tears, especially when your child is tired. The NHS and the AAP agree on the basics:
- Stay calm. Losing your temper or shouting back will not end the tantrum (NHS).
- Find out why it's happening: tired, hungry, frustrated?
- Distract if you can, or wait for it to stop, keeping your child safe.
- Don't change your mind to end the tantrum; the next transition will be harder if crying moves bath time (NHS).
If tantrums are very frequent, very long, include your child hurting themselves or others, or continue well past 4, talk to your child's doctor or health visitor.


This guide is general information for parents and carers, not medical advice. Every child is different; if you're worried about your child's behaviour or development, talk to your child's doctor.
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Top Tips for Surviving Tantrums
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Creating Positive Experiences for Toddlers & Preschool-Age Children
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Emotional Development: 2 Year Olds
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Screen Time & Temper Tantrums
- NHS: Temper tantrums
- CDC: Tips for Relying on Routines and Rules
- CDC: Tips for Giving Directions
- CDC: Milestones by 30 Months and by 3 Years
- Cote CA, Thompson RH, McKerchar PM. The effects of antecedent interventions and extinction on toddlers' compliance during transitions. J Appl Behav Anal, 2005
- Wilder DA, et al. Brief functional analysis and treatment of tantrums associated with transitions in preschool children. J Appl Behav Anal, 2006
- Brewer AT, et al. Advance Notice for Transition-Related Problem Behavior: Practice Guidelines. Behav Anal Pract, 2014
All sources checked 20 November 2026.